Image
LEBANON, OH -- Warren County commissioners unanimously denied a request to rezone approximately 30 acres in Union Township during their Tuesday, Nov. 17, meeting, following months of discussion over a construction business operating near residential properties.
The request, submitted by Tyler Holden of Blue Rock Properties LLC, sought to change the zoning of property at 2300 Lebanon Road from Mixed-Use Neighborhood (MXUN) to Light Industrial Manufacturing with a Planned Unit Development (I-1 PUD).
The proposed change would have allowed construction-related activities that are not currently permitted under the property's existing zoning designation.
The decision followed several public hearings in which neighboring property owners expressed concerns about heavy equipment, material storage and the impact of industrial activities near their homes.
During an earlier hearing, Holden indicated he might relocate heavy equipment and materials to adjoining property zoned for industrial use.
However, county planning officials explained Tuesday that the approximately 3.7-acre industrial-zoned portion of the neighboring property could not automatically be used for heavy equipment storage.
Under county zoning regulations, equipment storage is generally considered an accessory use, requiring an established permitted principal use. Additional zoning approvals could be necessary before such operations could begin.
Commissioners also discussed whether denying the rezoning would eliminate activities that neighbors found objectionable.
Commissioner Tom Grossmann questioned whether the applicant could continue operating a business office and conducting certain landscaping-related activities under the existing zoning.
County officials indicated that some uses might be permitted, although questions remained about the extent of those activities.
Before voting, commissioners discussed potential conditions that could have accompanied approval, including landscaping buffers, earthen mounds, trees and improvements to reduce dust from vehicle traffic.
Such measures could have provided additional screening between the business and surrounding residential properties.
However, neighboring residents maintained their opposition to the rezoning.
Grossmann cautioned that denying the request would also eliminate the county's opportunity to require those additional improvements as conditions of rezoning approval.
Commissioner David Young acknowledged the difficulty of balancing property owners' interests with neighborhood expectations.
He noted that the property's existing zoning establishes what activities are permitted and that commissioners were not obligated to approve an industrial zoning change.
Following the discussion, commissioners Shannon Jones, Tom Grossmann and David Young voted 3-0 to deny the request.
The denial leaves the property's existing Mixed-Use Neighborhood zoning in place.
It does not necessarily require the business to cease all operations. However, activities that violate existing zoning regulations remain subject to county enforcement.
The applicant may pursue other options, including relocating certain operations or seeking additional zoning approvals for another property.
For now, the commissioners' decision preserves the existing zoning designation, while questions about the property's future use may require further review.